Matias Aguayo and his Coméme crew gave retro disco and Chicago house grooves a blast of Latin percussion and raw dub effects without ever going for the lowest common denominator.

If there was a problem with the MUTEK atmosphere, though, it was this – that the crowds, while completely open to radically abstract sounds in the “art” music, seemed a little awkwardly resistant to getting stuck in to unfamiliar dance music. Conversations with Montreal’s own Anglophile DJ/producer Bowly, and Vancouver’s dubstep/ambient guru Kuma (“over for my one holiday of the year!”) threw some light on this: both talked of fighting against a conservatism in dance music, Bowly with his attempts to bring UK funky and garage to crowds only interested in the kind of buzz-saw dubstep that metal fans can understand, and Kuma complaining that there was a tendency for electronica fans to be ex-indie kids who only want things they can understand in indie rock terms. Both, though, saw MUTEK as an unreservedly positive force within this, happy in particular with this year’s UK bookings like Ikonika and King Midas Sound.

Bowly‘s own debut live set, in the second room of the huge Club Soda on Thursday night, worked in a similar way to Aguayo’s: freshening up old-school house music, and focusing on groove above all. Leaving aside the production finesse of his recorded work, he concentrated on jacking rhythms, joining dots between UK funky and the most percussive of Carl Craig’s work as 69. And while he got a good few people working a sweat up, the majority were in the main room, where first Jon Hopkins, then Mouse On Mars, then Nathan Fake – all artists capable of great subtlety – resorted to high-gloss pounding techno to fill the space. And it was very easy to see the rock/indie bias of the crowd, with many wigging out “down the front” but the majority taking it in as if they were “watching a show”.

All too often Ikonika lost her usual garage and booty-bass swing in favour of stuff that wouldn’t have been out of place in a fairly mainstream house club just about anywhere in the world…

This “watching” was much less of a problem going into the weekend, as more of Montreal’s party people came out, international techno/house became the main body of the festival, and a party mood kicked in. The first of the weekend’s two outdoor Piknik events was sadly washed out by torrential rain, so the second took place through Sunday afternoon in the dryer environs of the Metropolis club. This was a shame as the Piknik is by all accounts where Montreal’s more general music fans usually come out to join the clubbers, with thousands often in attendance – however the Sunday daytime punters were clearly having a great time and a good crowd of ordinary folk did turn out for an only mildly drizzly free outdoor show by Señor Coconut on Saturday evening.

It does, however become more difficult to pick out knockout musical moments, as all variety began to be subsumed under the relentless four-to-the-floor pulse. Live acts like Hamilton’s Orphx pressed all the usual “mnml” buttons, and even reliably great DJs like Henrik Schwarz, Dixon, Move D and PepĂ© Bradock began to blur together after a while – the latter in particular technically brilliant but full of so many familiar filter tricks and vamps that might or might not have been from some obscure Daft Punk or Green Velvet record that I began to feel I’d fallen back to 1997 and found myself longing for some kind of glitch or distortion just to break up the relentless professionalism of it all.

Even Ikonika, who I have seen do several of my absolute favourite DJ sets of the past year or so back in London, seemed to feel compelled towards the steady house beat. While her mixing was creative, and it was a great pleasure to hear UK funky tracks like Ill Blu’s Shystie remix on a huge rig, all too often she lost her usual garage / booty-bass swing in favour of stuff that wouldn’t have been out of place in a fairly mainstream house club just about anywhere in the world. As it happened, when she broke the regularity for one of her own brilliantly off-centre tracks, the crowd reacted well, but she seemed unsure and went back into the rock-solid beats before they could settle into this more interesting groove.

In amongst this, though, there was brilliance, sometimes with a straight house beat. In his live set, Actress aka Darren J Cunningham showed no interest in doing the obvious whatsoever. In fact, at first he seemed to be wilfully directionless, looping odd squiggly noises over and over, and the Friday night crowd full of burly hocky dudes and glam clubbers among the hipsters seemed nonplussed – but he was working at his own pace, drawing us all in, and as his unorthodox house rhythms picked up momentum so the most unlikely people started jigging along. Sadly technical foul-ups scuppered the end of his set, but not before he’d got the dancefloor under his control with impressive skill and confidence.

It was at moments like this – when the club crowds proved that they could be just as open as those in the theatre to the avant garde – that MUTEK really showed its strength. Both the Moritz Von Oswald Trio and Demdike Stare lulled their crowds into a hypnagogic state with loping dub-techno grooves, then hit them with strangeness, whether it was the off-kilter clatter of Vladislav Delay’s metallic percussion for the Trio, or Demdike Stare’s collapsing of their sound into thickly-mixed horror movie drones. Although their recorded work is almost gentle in its approach, King Midas Sound underlayed Roger Robinson’s delicate vocals with so much weapons-grade sub-bass and dense distortion that the effect came bizarrely close to My Bloody Valentine’s blend of narcotic melody and sonic ordeal; the wild eyes and sweat-drenched faces of certain crowd members after this set spoke volumes.

King Midas Sound came bizarrely close to My Bloody Valentine’s blend of narcotic melody and sonic ordeal.

Local hero Tim Hecker took a more gentle approach to shoegaze-style layers of sound, seducing his listeners with low-volume harmonies before building to frankly saucy crescendos; a later collaboration with a shirtless Ben Frost was far less successful, although this turned out to be due to technological meltdown. A particularly beautiful moment came when a club crowd was gradually drawn together by Carl Michael von Hauswolff‘s slow transformation of painful feedback tones into a lush, enveloping thrum; watching people’s faces turn from puzzlement or annoyance to enjoyment and then to complete absorption was as pleasurable as the music itself. All of these, however, were again taken as “shows”; like the Hopkins/MoM/Fake night, the audience was very much “taking it in” for the most part rather than getting as involved as they did with the club DJs.

If all this sounds like I’m polarising the lineup into exciting noise and dub acts vs more conservative house and techno – well, it was a little bit like that…but not entirely. Theo Parrish ended the festival with an excellent set: although it took he took his sweet time to get going and had problems with a faulty deck, Theo eventually sent the crowd completely wild with his trademark filter sweeps and astounding mixes which combined gloriously raw, obscure, early house tracks with Afrobeat and new wave electro-disco. This, like the brilliant sets earlier in the festival from the ComĂ©me crew and Bowly, showed exactly how viable and exciting house music still is, particularly when taken back to its first principles and given a bit of rhythmic variation.

And there was nothing wrong with any of the bookings in the house-led parts of the festival per se; every act taken alone was great. But with so many exciting post-dubstep, post-garage, post-hiphop syncopations going on out there in club music around the world, a little more variation would have been nice – and more out-there dance acts like Actress showed that even if the crowds were a little resistant to unfamiliar structures at first, they could be won over. MUTEK is a truly great thing, and it’s not for nothing that it’s grown steadily over eleven years and woven itself into the fabric of Montreal’s cultural life. But if they could apply to their dance bookings some of the same adventurousness and variety that lead to acts like Matmos, King Midas Sound and even the gloriously odd spectacle of The Caretaker being treated like pop stars – a Brackles here, a Rustie there, a Joker or Ras G dotted about the place maybe – it could be absolutely world-beating. But that quibble aside, for me, the sight of James Leyland Kirby, puzzled and drunk but clearly delighted as he bathed in rapturous applause for what was essentially a deeply odd and emotionally involved piece of performance art will stay with me for a long time to come. I rather think his expectations were as confounded as mine were by this brilliantly open-minded city and festival.

Joe Muggs
mutek.org

This entry was posted on Monday, June 14th, 2010 at 1:31 pm and is filed under Uncategorized. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.