Remix albums tend to get a bad rep, and deservedly so.

Most remix albums are opportunistic abominations, hastily cobbled together either in an attempt to reinvigorate the fortunes of an artist or album that has been selling poorly, or simply to colonise the potentially profitable “dance” market. Linkin Park’s Re-Animation, anyone?

Of course, there’s another side to the coin: beginning with Jamaican dub and the early days of disco, there have been remix albums that have amounted to more than the sum of their parts, giving radical producers the opportunity to shine and demonstrating the richness and depth of the source material. Over the next few pages, we highlight 20 landmark remix albums to have been released after dub and disco; albums which, even if not entirely successful, are at least laudable in their ambition.

THE FLYING LIZARDS
THE SECRET DUB LIFE OF THE FLYING LIZARDS
(CREATION, 1997)

In 1978, David Cunningham was commissioned by Virgin’s Front Line imprint to remix a collection of songs by reggae singer Jah Lloyd – he accepted, only to be presented with a mono tape master. “So I began to invent (or perhaps re-invent) techniques of editing, looping, filtering and subtraction to deal with unremixable mono material (these were the days before samplers),” he recalls. The finished work, which didn’t see release until 1995, is one of the most engrossing, oneiric dub albums you’ll ever hear, bringing to mind – among other things – Arthur Russell’s World Of Echo.

PRIMAL SCREAM / ADRIAN SHERWOOD
ECHO DEK
(CREATION, 1997)

Having lapsed into lazy Stones pastiche with Give Out But Don’t Give Up, Primal Scream thoroughly reinvented themselves for 1997′s Vanishing Point, recruiting Stone Roses’ Mani on bass and making the most of their obsession with cult road movies, motorik krautrock and Jamaican dub. It made perfect sense to invite On-U-Sound lynchpin Adrian Sherwood to have a go at remixing the whole shebang: Echo Dek amplifies Vanishing Point‘s audio surrealism, bass-weight and air of barely contained paranoia tenfold, and is a lost classic waiting to be rediscovered.

THURSTON MOORE
ROOT
(LO RECORDINGS, 1998)

In 1998, Sonic Youth’s Thurston Moore sent 25 different one-minute guitar improvisations to around 100 visual artists and musicians, inviting them to reinterpret the material and send their work back. The album that arose out of the process is surprisingly coherent, and furthermore constitutes a who’s-who of 90s post-rock and experimental music, with the likes of Stereolab, Russell Haswell, V/Vm, David Cunningham, Merzbow, Bruce Gilbert and even Blur among the contributors.

SCION
ARRANGE AND PROCESS BASIC CHANNEL TRACKS
(TRESOR, 2002)

As much a DJ mix as a remix album, Arrange And Process Basic Channel Tracks finds DJ Pete and Rene Van Der Lowe re-editing of Moritz von Oswald and Mark Ernestus’s techno productions subtly, but in a way that also strongly emphasises their dub DNA. It ends up functioning as a kind of “best of” Basic Channel, an unbeatable one-stop shop for anyone looking to grasp the importance of their work; it’s also an admirably selfless offering, an act of admiration and tribute, from Scion to their mentors and forebears.

9TH WONDER
GOD’S STEPSON
(HIPHOPSITE.COM RECORDINGS, 2003)

An unofficial front-to-back remix version of Nas’s God’s Son, God’s Stepson predates – and, let’s face it, betters – The Grey Album, propelling 9th Wonder’s profile skywards and pushing his ascent to hip-hop production royalty into second gear.

MADLIB
SHADES OF BLUE
(BLUE NOTE, 2003)

In 2003, Madlib got a call from his beloved Blue Note, perhaps the greatest Jazz label in living memory, to see if he fancied trawling through their vast archive of master tapes and creating some remixes and new-from-old sample-based compositions in the spirit of his Yesterday’s New Quintet project. Naturally he jumped at the chance, and the product of his efforts, Shades Of Blue, is a bizarre ride through the work of the greats via Madlib’s skunk-powered sonic filter.

THROBBING GRISTLE
MUTANT THROBBING GRISTLE
(NOVAMUTE, 2004)

Double LP of TG dance refixes, notable especially for two impeccable reimaginings of ‘Hot On The Heels Of Love’: Carl Craig’s sweeping techno epic, and Simon Ratcliffe of Basement Jaxx’s more subtle but no less effective house edit.

DANGER MOUSE
THE GREY ALBUM
(SELF-RELEASED, 2004)

The concept sounded like something any one of us might have come up while talking nonsense down the pub: Jay-Z’s Black Album meshed together with The Beatles’ White Album to make (of course) The Grey Album. The difference between Danger Mouse and us was that he had the skill and dedication to make the concept a reality.

SOULWAX
NITE VERSIONS
(PIAS, 2005)

Though not exactly a sophisticate’s choice, Nite Versions is worth acknowledging: it saw the Dewaele Brothers apply everything they’d learned from their big-room electro mash-up project 2ManyDJs to the more conventional music of Soulwax, their pre-existing band, resulting in a new kind of muscular dance-rock that continues to decimate festivals and stadia the world over.

DUSK + BLACKDOWN VS GRIEVOUS ANGEL
MARGINS MUSIC: REDUX
(KEYSOUND, 2009)

Sheffield producer Grievous Angel has long been one of the UK’s most underrated artists, but even better than his productions are his meticulous Ableton DJ sets, which have mashed-up 2step, UK Funky and more to great effect. Here, he takes on Dusk & Blackdown’s debut album Margin’s Music, with full access to stems and acapellas, transforming its DNA into a continuous DJ set that climaxes with a breathtaking blend of Dusk’s ‘Focus’ and Trim’s vocal from ‘The Bits’.

RICARDO VILLALOBOS / MAX LODERBAUER
RE:ECM
(ECM, 2011)

Granted access to the catalogue of Manfred Eicher’s revered ECM label, Villalobos and Loderbauer turned out a double-album of three-dimensional dub versions remarkable in its surgical focus and attention to detail. It’s a little too precious to keep the casual listener entertained, but the rewards awaiting those up for deep immersion are endless. Whichever camp you fall into, you can’t deny that Re:ECM is a landmark in the evolution of the remix album.

KING MIDAS SOUND
WITHOUT YOU
(HYPERDUB, 2011)

Multi-producer remix albums are almost always bad, but when you have the taste and contacts of Kevin Martin and Kode9 – meaning you can call upon the likes of Hype Williams, Mala, Green Gartside (!) and Flying Lotus – chances are you’re going to buck the trend.